top of page

172 NARROW LANE EEAST

Headline (1).png

Shelter Island, NY 11964

MD-LD  $165K  |  YEAR-ROUND  $210K
JUNE  $35K  |  JULY  $70K  |  AUG  $70K  |  AUG-LD  $80K
2 WEEKS $35K

4  Beds  |   3 Baths

Exquisite Shelter Island Waterfront with Dock

One-of-a-kind immaculate Shelter Island Menantic Peninsula waterfront rental now available for the summer or year round. This exquisite 4 bedroom, light-filled home with full western facing sunset views, water facing decks and balconies has 2 primary en-suite bedrooms, one on the first floor with direct access to the waterfront porch, hot tub and outdoor shower and additional generous bedrooms on the 2nd floor all with views and king sized beds. The 2nd floor also has a study on the mezzanine and a multipurpose great room and balcony with full water views and sunsets. Room for 1 car in the garage, a dock for your boat and adeep water mooring. The slower, stress free living on the water in Shelter Island will make for the perfect summer. Close to beaches, marinas and wonderful restaurants on Shelter Island. Plan a bike ride or a kayak excursion. Close to Sag Harbor on the South Fork and Greenport on the North Fork. Listing ID: 936982

936982-1HB6yQy43dRqNRvZ.jpg
Property Details
4 Total Bedrooms
3 Full Baths
Interior Features
Hardwood Flooring
Open Kitchen
Two Primary En-Suite Bedrooms
Mezzanine Study
Fireplace
Alarm System
Central A/C (2 Zones)
Highlights
Waterfront Home
Western-Facing Sunset View
Multiple Outdoor Living Spaces
Located on Shelter Island’s Menantic Peninsula
Close to Beaches, Marinas & Restaurants
Exterior Features
Waterfront
Private Dock
Deep-Water Mooring
Water, Bay & Creek Views
Waterfront Decks and Balconies
Hot Tub
Outdoor Shower
Garage
Brown Harris Stevens Bridgehampton
Cynthia Barrett Real Estate Broker Shelter Island and The Hamptons
  • LOGO

© 2025 CYNTHIA BARRETT

This website is not the official website of Brown Harris Stevens LLC. Brown Harris Stevens LLC does not make any representation or warranty regarding any information, including without limitation its accuracy or completeness, contained on this website. Real estate agents affiliated with Brown Harris Stevens LLC are independent contractors and are not employees of Brown Harris Stevens LLC. All marks & copyrights are the property of their respective owners and used with permission. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Brown Harris Stevens Policy Standard Operating Procedures for Prospective Homebuyers
Prior to showing a homebuyer a property or providing services: (1) BHS does not require identification from a prospective homebuyer; (2) BHS does not require a homebuyer to sign an exclusive brokerage agreement requiring the homebuyer to work only with BHS on all properties; and (3)  BHS does not require a pre-approval for a mortgage loan in order to show a homebuyer properties. However, based upon the requirements of the seller, the building in which the property is located, or others, some or all of the foregoing items may be required. Date: April 20, 2022

bottom of page