top of page
Iconic Captain Cartwright House - Shelter Island
Shelter Island, NY 11964
$44K WINTER  |  $95K YEAR ROUND

5 Beds  |   3 Baths  |  1.13 Acre

Classic Captain Cartwright House

Designers own fabulous reconstruction and renovation of the Classic and Iconic Captain Cartwright House in Shelter Island. This classic 5 bedroom home, detached garage, covered porches, blue stone patios and heated 20 x 40 gunite pool with all the bells and whistles is centrally located between the South and the North Ferries and across the street from the 2350 acre Mashomack Preserve on Shelter Island. The very private setting is ideal for relaxing by the chic lounging areas around the pool or entertaining summer guests on the beautifully landscaped grounds perfect for intimate dinners. An oversized outdoor shower is a show stopper. This so very special summer getaway is now available for the first time and will not last.

909434-20.jpg
Property Details

5 Total Bedrooms

3 Full Baths

1.13 Acres

2 Story

No Pets Allowed

Highlights

Across from Mashomack Preserve

Private landscaped grounds and Classic Coastal Charm

Interior Features

Eat-In Kitchen

Hardwood Flooring

Furnished

Primary Bedroom with En Suite Bath & Walk-In Closet

Central A/C

Exterior Features

Detached 2-Car Garage

Heated Gunite Pool (20 X 40)

Deck & Patio

Covered Porch

Outdoor Shower

Brown Harris Stevens Bridgehampton
Cynthia Barrett Real Estate Broker Shelter Island and The Hamptons
  • LOGO

© 2025 CYNTHIA BARRETT

This website is not the official website of Brown Harris Stevens LLC. Brown Harris Stevens LLC does not make any representation or warranty regarding any information, including without limitation its accuracy or completeness, contained on this website. Real estate agents affiliated with Brown Harris Stevens LLC are independent contractors and are not employees of Brown Harris Stevens LLC. All marks & copyrights are the property of their respective owners and used with permission. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Brown Harris Stevens Policy Standard Operating Procedures for Prospective Homebuyers
Prior to showing a homebuyer a property or providing services: (1) BHS does not require identification from a prospective homebuyer; (2) BHS does not require a homebuyer to sign an exclusive brokerage agreement requiring the homebuyer to work only with BHS on all properties; and (3)  BHS does not require a pre-approval for a mortgage loan in order to show a homebuyer properties. However, based upon the requirements of the seller, the building in which the property is located, or others, some or all of the foregoing items may be required. Date: April 20, 2022

bottom of page